tschwab asks an intersting question: Is your government serving you, or is it telling you what to do and how to do it?
First, I think it is important to realize that this question is asking for positive (as opposed to normative) analysis. In other words, what does the government do, now what should it do. For the sake of full disclosure, I will admit that I believe the government should serve the people. The relationship between the people and the U.S. government is one where the people legitimize the government’s power. This is important to note because it is no a relationship where the government legitimizes the people’s power, something inherent in the idea of ‘telling you what to do and how to do it’.
That said, what do I think the government is doing right now? I think there are two ways to look at this problem. One, on a very superficial level. Two, on a foundational level.
Let’s go backwards. Two. The government is clearly telling us what to do and how to do it. By contributing to a structure for society, the government formulates standards for how we act. This is embodied in the spirit of the law. Have you ever waited at a red light when no traffic is coming? A simple example, yes, but also a telling one. The law literally tells us how to act. We empower it to do so. And in doing so, as a society we employ a balancing test, by sacrificing some autonomy, the government can serve us in a better way than we could acting independently.
One. The more superficial level. I have already hinted at this a little bit. The purpose of laws sanctioned by the people is to sacrifice some of their own autonomy for a greater benefit. Therefore, the government is actively serving us on its function in so much as we agree to the contract we have created with the government by becoming citizens.
There is more room for interpretation on this subject, but I’m ignoring lecture by writing this, so I’ll leave it to everyone else.








Recent Comments